Why is it that my website was getting zero to 10 searches a month, and now it's getting a thousand searches a month, and yet the dial has not moved in terms of revenue? More traffic does not equal more revenue. You need the right traffic in order to generate more revenue.
Hello everyone, Michael Santiago here with another episode of the Arising Co podcast, Found, Trusted and Chosen. We're really helping business owners like yourselves get found online, whether it's through Google, ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, all the AI agents out there. Whether it's to be trusted, right? Getting your reviews up, knowing all the strategies and all the things you need to be undertaking, so that when people land on your website they can sense that they can trust you. And then chosen, right? What's the website experience like? What differentiates you from your competitors, so that the traffic that found you on the website actually chooses you?
So today, what are we going to be talking about? It's Episode 4, and I wanted to title it something along the lines of "Your website is getting traffic, but why aren't any customers converting?" That's the topic for today, because it's something that happens multiple times. I mean, to clients that are tracking the analytics on their website, so they know that they're getting traffic but they're not converting, and to those that are not tracking any analytics at all. They're not getting any kind of revenue, but they didn't realize that they were getting traffic, and all they had to do was change some things on their website that would then help bring those people to their front door.
So tune in, because we're going to go over some practical steps you can apply, so that you can not only understand and see where you're currently at in terms of the traffic visiting your website, but also understand the weak elements on your website that could be vastly improved, so that your people end up converting into customers.
You're investing in search engine optimization, maybe AI engine optimization now, and generative engine optimization. You're investing in Google Ads or Meta ads or TikTok ads, right? So you're focused on actually getting found, but nothing seems to be moving the dial in terms of converting into a customer. You're seeing that the clicks are there, right? Your CTR, which is click-through rate, may be high, above the industry average, and yet no one is actually converting.
And there are multiple things that can be happening, right? You can have the wrong audience, or maybe the website experience is incredibly lacking. And so that's what we're going to talk about today. It's really more about the website experience.
One of the first things I always tell clients is that more traffic does not necessarily equate to more revenue. "And why is that, Michael? Why is it that my website was getting zero to 10 searches a month, and now it's getting a thousand searches a month, and yet the dial has not moved in terms of revenue?" The reason is that it depends on what is bringing that traffic into your website.
Let me give you an example. We served a client who was getting about 1,000 to 1,200 searches a month from Google alone. But all of that traffic was coming in through an educational article that did not attract their customer whatsoever. It was more of an entertaining, cool-to-know piece in their industry, but not at all relevant to someone actually wanting to make a purchase.
And so although they're getting all of this traffic, maybe you have some outliers, where someone sees it, it's cool, and then they just happen to have a need for what that company provides, and so they reach out, right? That would be awesome. But that wasn't the case, and it's most likely not the case for many people out there who are currently experiencing that.
So more traffic does not equate to more revenue. You need to make sure that you get the right traffic, via proper pages that actually target keywords or phrases your clients are actually searching. Whether it's ChatGPT, Claude, or Google, whatever it is they're searching for, you've got to make sure that you have a standout page that answers those specific needs.
And now with AI, it's a little bit more robust, because AI doesn't just focus on a singular page. It also digs into the full context of your website. And so higher volume favors AI search. If your website has a higher volume of great context for your type of services, then AI will heavily favor you.
For example, we were just helping a car service company. They drive people from Orlando airport over to Disney, or over to Universal Studios or Epic Universe. They don't really have a lot of reviews. They're competing against a lot of big-name people. They're more like a freelancer.
So what ended up happening? We redesigned the website and created proper pages based on keyword research. Keyword research, you're going to hear me say a lot when it comes to this kind of topic, because keyword research is what helps you understand what people are actually searching for. You have sites like Semrush, Ubersuggest, Ahrefs. These are keyword research tools. And Google has a Keyword Planner as well. These are essentially tools where you can see, oh, "AC repair Orlando" gets 1,000 searches a month, compared to another keyword that maybe only gets zero to 10 searches a month.
Depending on those factors, there's a lot you can do to make sure you're selecting the right keywords for where your website is at the present. If you end up going for the higher-volume keywords, some of them are very competitive. Some of them are very difficult to get into. And if you're a brand new website, you don't have enough backlinks or reputation or trust to have a reasonable rank for those keywords.
That doesn't mean you shouldn't try, because AI now actually picks up on pages that are not ranking on page one on Google. If the content there solves the dilemma or the problem a customer is searching for on ChatGPT or Claude, then they'll recommend you. And that's exactly what happened.
I told them, "Hey, get ready for some extra business. This is what's going to happen." And it followed through. We redesigned, created the necessary pages, and lo and behold, within two to three weeks... because we're tracking everything. We've got the trackers, some conversion trackers, some session recordings and so on, so we can really see how the traffic coming in is navigating through the pages and where it's coming from.
What ended up happening was that he started getting requests for quotes for car rides on future dates, something he hadn't really been generating. A lot of his business was more in the present, not so much out in the future. And so now he's got these leads, and they found him through AI search, predominantly through ChatGPT. So how could that be? It's only been two to three weeks since the website launched, and yet the website was recommended to this person, who then requested a quote.
That's an example of, first off, us doing really good work: keyword research, competitor analysis, making sure that the pages we build are actually going to rank, build impressions, build backlinks and so on. More traffic does not equal more revenue, but the right traffic does. We created the right pages to attract the right traffic, so that it leads to the right revenue. Well, more revenue.
So, really honing in on this point: more traffic does not equal more revenue. You need the right traffic in order to generate more revenue.
Secondly, the five-second test. "What's the five-second test, Michael?" The five-second test is simple. You boot up a web page, and in the first five seconds you should be able to know what the offer is, who it's for, and why. Like, why do I even need it? Psychologically, those three things are always there, whether we realize it or not. And a lot of web pages nowadays don't answer those three criteria in five seconds. You have to scroll down to see much more, and by then you're just confused. And I love when a good friend of mine says, "If you confuse, you lose." So stop confusing.
Five-second test: pull up your own website and actually see. What am I offering? Who is it for? And why? Do I cover that in the hero section, or the section right under the hero? It should be right there above the fold, in that top area, because from the data we collect across our clients, seldom does anyone actually go through the entire page, unless it's a really refined landing page funnel. And most times your homepage is not that. So check out your website, and if you can't answer those within five seconds, refine it. Refine your stuff.
Obviously, if you have analytics and you're tracking things, and your homepage is already doing well, check whether you're actually landing a lot of traffic before you change things. If you do get a lot of traffic, you want to be very careful with your changes, so as not to lose some of the traffic you're ranking for. So make sure you do that first.
But most times, people don't take the time to do the five-second test. And so it's very difficult, when traffic comes to their website, for people to actually buy or pursue their services.
So, the five-second test again. What is the offer? Who is it for? And why? And that why had better be compelling. That why had better tell me exactly what my pain points and struggles are, and how your solution, your offer, is actually going to remedy them and alleviate all of my symptoms and issues. Make it a no-brainer, so that I actually want to pursue a conversation and dialogue, and we can work toward a win-win situation where you get paid and my problem gets solved. That's the five-second test.
The third thing has everything to do with the five-second test: unclear messaging, and bad calls to action or no calls to action. I remember going to multiple websites where there were no calls to action, and the contact form was all the way at the end. There were no buttons. I could clearly tell what it was and who it was for, but you had to scroll so long just to get to the contact form. And at some point the experience was so bad that the contact form broke on mobile, not on desktop. So you just have an amalgam of things.
You want to make sure you have clarity in your messaging, your offer, everything, but also have calls to action. Your hero section, the beginning section of your website, should have an immediate call to action. Every page should serve a purpose: to bring people closer to your desired goal and outcome. If your desired goal is to sell your particular service, then your landing page and your other pages should have calls to action that bring people closer to that.
Do not confuse the reader with multiple calls to action, because when you do, they get lost. Take a homepage. Let's say you provide AC repair, but you also have a free guide that helps people fix their AC issues or something like that. They can put in their email, sign up for the newsletter, and get this PDF guide. Well, if you have that PDF guide, and also a regular newsletter call to action, on the same page as your repair and emergency service, make sure that your emergency repair, your main service, is the most dominant thing. Keep the PDF guide and the newsletter all the way at the bottom. Do not put them in the navigation menu.
If you have social media icons in your top navigation menu, remove them, because they're just a distraction. You've brought people to your website. Why would you want them to go to social media because they see the Facebook logo or the Instagram or TikTok or X logo? Why would you want them to leave? You're just inviting them to have a different thought: "Oh man, I forgot to reply to this person. Oh man, I wonder how my post is doing. Let me go." And all of a sudden, you've lost them. Keep that stuff in the footer. You don't need it at the top. That's just an extra bonus for you.
So, unclear messaging and calls to action. Make sure the right call to action is the dominant one on the page.
Now, what you really want to think about is how customers actually make decisions. Because you may be getting a lot of traffic to the website, but you're not getting revenue. Part of the solution to that problem, I would say, is putting yourself in your customer's shoes. How are they making decisions, and why is this important?
There's an outdoor living company, a luxury company, that we've served continuously for two years now. We learned that their buying cycle, from the first time someone lands on their website to actually requesting a quote or a phone call, is anywhere from zero to six months. We're able to track that through cookies and other things.
Oftentimes people get very discouraged with marketing, because they see these numbers, people going to their website, but it doesn't bring a return. Because they're not tracking that data, or giving it a long enough road, they fail to realize that customer A, who signed up for their service four months after the initial marketing happened, was there when the initial marketing happened. And the reason they came back in the fourth month is that the initial marketing happened, and now was the right time for them to purchase. But a lot of business owners don't know that, or don't hire the right people to be able to know that.
So if that's you, and you're realizing, "Man, I don't have the analytics. I'm not sure that we're actually tracking all of our marketing efforts," give us a call. You already know how to reach us; it's all in the description. Because that's something you ought to know as a business owner, or whoever it is you hired, your internal team. If you need any kind of training, that's what we offer at Arising Co. We don't just fulfill things for you; we can also train your team if you'd like to keep everything in house. Shameless plug there.
But that's what we learned for that company. And there's another company where it's almost immediate. It's zero to two weeks. That's the buying cycle for their prospects.
So you have to know that too. Know how a customer makes decisions. Higher-ticket items tend to have a longer buying cycle. Smaller-ticket items are fairly quick, because there's not much risk. If I wanted an outdoor living company to build me a really nice outdoor living space and backyard, and it's going to cost me $200,000, you best believe I'm going to do a lot of diligent research. I'm going to be going through your website, but I may not be able to make the decision now, because I also want to vet you and compare you against other competitors. So understand your customer's decision-making process. That will be very beneficial for you.
If you have all your services on one page, as opposed to individual service pages, that's one of the first things you need to correct right now. The reason is that you want every page to do its work. If you have a general services page that doesn't really dive deep into each particular service you offer, fix that. Individual pages, with testimonials and case studies for each service you provide, are additional meat that Google and AI search can benefit from, so they can better rank you and better serve the people whose questions ChatGPT and Google are trying to answer. So you definitely want to be doing that.
And when you're seeing all the traffic, maybe you have Google Search Console set up, or Google Analytics. If you don't, set those things up, and have the proper privacy policies on your website. The reason is that you want to be able to track the analytics. You want to know how much traffic you're getting. And if you're already tracking these things, you want to know the engagement time. How long are they spending on your website? Are they going across different pages? Google Analytics does that really well. You have other ones too, like Zoho PageSense, Ahrefs tracking, Plausible. There are so many more. Reach out to us if you need help with that.
These are just some practical improvements you can make. But overall, the big picture is really your experience and your messaging. If I can encompass everything into one thing to help you, the person who wants to learn all this so that your website gets the traffic and also converts it into customers: just make sure the experience is spot-on for that customer. Clearly offer what it is you're solving their issues with, how, and why.
Trust factors and signals, like having a proper About page with your picture and your team, really start showing more of the human connection, so that people can relate to a human as opposed to AI. Because nowadays a lot of AI websites are being made, and a lot of them fail to include human photos or human likeness. And so a lot of people are getting duped into thinking that some companies are legitimate when they're really not. Some of them are sort of like an Angie's List, where they take your request and then pass you along as a lead to a company that can actually do what you were requesting. Some of them are trying to do that service for you, but they're brand new. They have no experience or skin in the game, but they whipped up a website that you fell prey to, and now you're under the punishment, I would say, of their domain.
We're serving a client now, and that's the issue he's having. He had an inexperienced agency build him an AI website that did not have the relevant information. This client does not do deposits or reservations. And as we're doing their ads for them and redoing their website properly, he's realizing, "Wait, what? It's been in there for a year? We don't do deposits. We don't do reservations. Where is this coming from?" And that website was live for a whole year.
So again, make sure things are taken care of. Look at the messaging across your website and make sure it resonates with your customer, but also that it resonates with the experience and aligns with what you actually do and your values. Don't let AI dictate those things, because AI will say certain things that may not be truthful. Make sure the content that's on your website actually represents who you are and who your business is.
So, just to summarize again: your website's getting traffic, so why aren't you getting customers? These are the kinds of things you ought to be doing. Come with the mindset that more traffic does not mean more revenue, but the right traffic does. Make sure the five-second test applies to your customers when they land on your website. Do they know what it is that you do? Who is it for? Is it for me? And why? How is it going to solve my problem?
And maybe go into purpose. Why are you doing the thing that you're doing? Because people love to have a connection with a greater purpose. So if you end up donating a portion to XYZ, feel free to share that, because there are people out there who align with those things and will choose to purchase from you. Only if you're actually going to do it, though. Don't just put it in there, because then you're lying.
Make sure you have clear messaging, with every page having proper calls to action. Make sure you know the customer buying process, the buying time. Not everyone has the same buying time. Some people can buy right away, but some things take longer, and knowing that helps you keep your expectations in the proper place. And ultimately, the big picture again: make sure the website experience is clean, everything works, and the messaging is very tight.
I hope you guys enjoyed Episode 4. I had a blast doing this. Share your comments with me. Send me an email at michael@thearising.co. All that information is in the description. I'd love to know where you currently stand and what you need help with. And I invite you: what are some topics you want to know more about that I can cover in future episodes? I do this to serve you, so all of that information is incredibly helpful for me to put together a good episode schedule, so that you guys benefit the most.
So with that said, I'm Michael Santiago with Arising Co. Go to thearising.co and check out our free SEO audit. We'd love to help you assess where your website currently stands. If you're the person this episode is for, where your website's getting traffic but it's not converting, we'll be able to give you an audit for that, and hopefully we'll be able to engage in business and actually help serve you. But if not, the free SEO audit at least helps you know where you currently are, where you need to be, and where your competitors are, so you have a signpost for what you're supposed to do so your business can grow.
With that said, hope to see you guys in the next episode. Thank you so much for listening to the Found, Trusted and Chosen podcast, where we help you and your company be found, trusted and chosen by your customers. Take care.