Case Study - A Counseling Website Rebuilt to Be Found, With 80% More Clicks from Google

Pinnacle Counseling Institute is a nonprofit counseling practice in Winter Park, Florida. Its old website was hard to use on a phone and gave Google little to go on, with no page for any of its services. We rebuilt it and wrote a page for every service, nearby city and counselor. In its first 65 days, clicks from Google rose 80%.

Client
Pinnacle Counseling Institute
Year
Service
Website Redesign, Local SEO & AI Search

01The Problem

A caring practice that was hard to find

Good counselors, on a site Google could barely place.

Pinnacle Counseling Institute is a nonprofit counseling practice on Howell Branch Road in Winter Park, Florida. Its counselors see individuals, couples, teens, young adults and families in person, and by telehealth throughout Florida.

The practice was not being found well enough. People searching Google for counseling nearby, and people asking AI assistants for a recommendation, were not reaching it as often as they should have.

The old Webflow site gave search engines little to go on. The homepage title was just the practice's name, with no service or city. Its search description called it the "best counseling and mental health therapy in Orlando," though the office is in Winter Park. There was no page for any service: trauma, relationships, stress and the rest were six headings on the About page. Nothing in the code told search engines what kind of business it was, where it was or when it was open, and the Facebook and Instagram icons linked to those sites' home pages instead of the practice's own profiles.

It was also hard to use on a phone. The homepage loaded with its menu laid over the headline, and the page was wider than the screen, with menu items running off the right edge.

The old Pinnacle Counseling Institute Webflow homepage on a laptop and on a phone, where the menu covers the headline
Before: the old Webflow siteThe old homepage on a laptop and on a phone. On the phone, the menu loads over the headline and runs off the edge of the screen.

02What They Wanted

Found, trusted and easy to reach out to

The goal was a website that feels like the practice itself: warm, unhurried and clear about what happens next.

Found for the searches that matter

When someone in Winter Park searches for help with anxiety, trauma or their marriage, Pinnacle should be in the results, and in the answers AI assistants give.

A calm first impression

Someone reaching out for counseling is often having a hard week. The site should feel calm, look trustworthy and work on the phone in their hand.

An easy first step

Visitors should be able to understand their options, find the right counselor and book a consultation without having everything figured out first.

03What Was at Stake

Help that goes to whoever shows up first

For a nonprofit whose mission is to make counseling more accessible, every person who cannot find it is someone who may face a difficult season alone.

Clients who book somewhere else

Choosing a counselor often comes down to a single search session. If the practice did not appear for those searches, people ready to begin would book with whoever did.

Placed in the wrong city

A site that described the practice as an Orlando provider, with no page for Winter Park or for any service, gave Google and AI assistants little reason to recommend it to someone nearby.

A first impression that works against them

If a phone visitor’s first view was a menu covering the headline, some would close the tab before learning what the practice offers.

04The Pathway

We rebuilt the site around how people look for a counselor

One gentle next step at a time.

We redesigned the site, rebuilt it on WordPress and wrote all of its copy, and it launched on September 10, 2026. Each part of the site answers a question someone has before they reach out to a counselor.

  1. 01

    Open with calm and a clear next step

    The homepage now opens with "You do not have to walk through this alone," names Winter Park and telehealth throughout Florida, and offers two ways in: Schedule Session, or a free 15-minute consultation with a counselor. Just below, Start Where You Are gives three paths for wherever a visitor is: ready to begin, looking for the right counselor, or still exploring their options.

    Start where you are section on the Pinnacle Counseling Institute homepage with three paths
    Start where you areThree gentle paths, so nobody has to have everything figured out before reaching out.
  2. 02

    Give every service its own page

    The old site had no service pages. We wrote 21, grouped the way people think about their needs: Counseling Services, Specialized Therapy, and Life Experiences and Support. Each page explains who it serves, what it helps with and how a counselor helps, so it can answer the exact search someone makes, from "EMDR therapist Winter Park" to "spiritual abuse counseling."

    The Services menu open on the Pinnacle Counseling Institute website, listing 18 services in three groups
    Every service, one menuThe Services menu groups the practice's care into three clear columns.
    Trauma and EMDR Therapy page on the Pinnacle Counseling Institute website
    Trauma & EMDR TherapyEach service page speaks to the person searching, then lays out who it serves, what it helps with and how.
  3. 03

    Tell Google and AI assistants where the practice is

    The homepage title now reads "Counseling in Winter Park, FL." Winter Park has its own page, and so do Maitland, Orlando, Casselberry and Altamonte Springs. Behind the scenes, structured data tells search engines and AI assistants that Pinnacle is a counseling practice at its Winter Park address, with its phone number, opening hours, the areas it serves and links to its real Facebook, Instagram and LinkedIn profiles.

    Counseling in Winter Park, Florida page on the Pinnacle Counseling Institute website
    Counseling in Winter ParkA page written for the city the practice actually serves, instead of a description that placed it in Orlando.
  4. 04

    Introduce every counselor

    Choosing a counselor is personal, so we wrote a profile for every counselor, with their credentials, the people they work with and how they approach counseling. The homepage introduces them with cards that say who each one helps, and each profile ends in a clear next step, usually a free consultation.

    Meet our counselors section on the Pinnacle Counseling Institute homepage with counselor cards
    Meet the counselorsCredentials, specialties and who each counselor works with, before anyone picks up the phone.
  5. 05

    Make it work on a phone

    Every page now reshapes itself for the screen it is on. On a phone the menu folds neatly behind a button, a Schedule button stays in the header, and the consultation buttons are full width and easy to tap.

    Three phone screens of the new Pinnacle Counseling Institute website: the homepage, the Trauma and EMDR page and the Start where you are section
    Built for phonesThe homepage, a service page and the three starting paths, on a phone.
  6. 06

    Carry the old addresses over

    The old counselor and blog addresses now redirect to their new pages, so the search history they had earned was not thrown away.

  7. 07

    Measure it

    In November 2026 we compared the first 65 days after launch with the 65 days before in Google Search Console, search by search, and checked which visitors arrived from AI assistants.

What we delivered

  • Website Redesign
  • WordPress
  • Copywriting
  • Service Pages
  • Local SEO
  • AI Search Readiness
  • Structured Data
  • Search Console Review

05The Result

80% more clicks, and a place in Winter Park searches

+80%

Clicks from Google: 505 in the first 65 days, up from 281

283

Clicks in October 2026, its best month on record

2 → 39

Winter Park searches showing the practice 15+ times

In the 65 days from September 10 to November 13, 2026, the new site earned 505 clicks from Google search, up from 281 in the 65 days before, an increase of 80%. It was shown 12,852 times, up 44%, and the share of people who clicked rose from 3.1% to 3.9%.

October was its best month on record. The site earned 283 clicks from Google in October 2026. In the Search Console data we have, which goes back to May 2025, no other month had passed 171.

Growth came from both directions. Searches for the practice by name sent 222 clicks, up from 135. Every other search, from specific therapies to "counseling near me," sent 283, up from 146.

Where the clicks came from
Page65 days after launch (clicks)65 days before launch (clicks)
All searches505281
Every search except the practice name283146
Searches for the practice by name222135
Where the clicks came fromClicks from Google search, September 10 to November 13, 2026, against July 7 to September 9. Source: Google Search Console, web search. Name searches are those containing “pinnacle”; the rest is our own subtraction.

People searching for Pinnacle now find the right one. Other practices share the name, so "pinnacle counseling" is a crowded search. The site's average position for it rose from 5.3 to 2.7, and the share of searchers who chose it rose from 14% to 43%.

Winter Park searches now include the practice. Before launch, only 2 searches naming Winter Park showed the site 15 or more times. Since launch, 39 have, together showing it 2,583 times. They include "therapist winter park fl" (234 times), "therapist near me winter park fl" (120 times, at an average position of 7.5) and "winter park counseling" (55 times, at 2.2). Because the site is now tested for dozens of searches it never appeared for, its overall average position reads lower on paper, 14.7 against 9.9.

The next gains are on page two. Most of the new Winter Park searches have not turned into clicks yet. The site sits around positions 11 to 14 for searches such as "trauma therapy winter park," "EMDR therapist winter park fl" and "anxiety therapist winter park fl," just off the first page. Moving them onto page one is the next step.

AI assistants are sending people too. Since visitor tracking began in October, 17 people have arrived from ChatGPT and 1 from Gemini, and the ChatGPT visitors stayed about four minutes on average.

Pinnacle Counseling Institute has been working with Michael Santiago with Arising Co this summer to redo our website. We have recently gone LIVE (still working on some updates) and are thrilled with the work his company has provided. With so much changing online with how business are found, you need to reach out to him and his team, they will take great care of you.

Caroline Tiell
Caroline TiellDevelopment & Community Engagement Strategist, Pinnacle Counseling Institute

Sound familiar?

When someone near you finally searches for help, is your practice the one they find?

Pinnacle's new site meets people in a hard moment with a calm, clear next step, and Google now shows it for the searches they actually make. If you are facing the same problem and want a similar payoff, let's look at what your future clients are searching for.

No pressure and no pitch deck. We will tell you honestly whether we are the right fit.

More case studies

A Free Clinic Website, Rebuilt for Patients in English and Spanish

Ann Silverman Community Health Clinic gives free medical, dental, behavioral health and social services to uninsured Bucks County residents, and a good portion of the people it serves speak Spanish. We replaced its dated Wix site with a modern, mobile-friendly website, translated every page into Spanish and built it so Google can show the Spanish pages to people searching in Spanish.

Read more

A Construction-Focused Redesign That Brought Two Leads in Its First Month

Helping Companies places remote professionals inside construction companies, but its old website sold general virtual assistants to seven unrelated industries. We redesigned it around construction buyers. The new site brought two leads in its first month, and clicks from Google are up 161%.

Read more